Skip to content

Market Perspectives

Are we just gambling?

Tags: Probabilities · Randomness

By Raonak Ahmad

Ever think about how many decisions you make in a day? Or even every few minutes? Probably too many to count. You rely on synthesizing information available to you - in some cases consciously and in other cases subtly. Whether you're aware of it or not, you're trying to make decisions leading to your desired outcomes.

Every decision has a set of known and unknown outcomes. Known outcomes are either what you do or don't want to see happen after your decision. Unknown outcomes are potential results of your decisions that are out of your realm of imagination. The information available to you and your synthesis thereof is critical in shaping your decision towards a desired outcome. Ideally your decision carries a 51% or more probability of achieving your desired outcome. The higher the percentage - the better. And another twist: good decisions do not always lead to good outcomes and bad decisions do not always lead to bad outcomes. In other words, you could make the best decision possible with a 99% win rate and still end up with an unfavorable outcome. The 1% loss rate is pure randomness at play and you got smacked.

Look at any price chart and you quickly see a collection of green and red bars going up and down in a never ending cycle. Looks random by any measure. Dig deeper and you start seeing repeatable patterns. Go further and you see patterns repeat at certain times of the day coincident with other extraneous events. Start tracking and assigning probabilities to certain scenario pairings and you've got a set of probable outcomes in a defined environment.

We are not gambling if we do our homework first. A gambler bets on random outcomes carrying 50/50 odds. Pure chance, heads or tails. A professional deeply understands a few key concepts like when to take risks, risk management, and expectancy. A professional also exhibits a high degree of discipline - namely, self-control.

Let's get into it...

When to Take the Bet

The mind often plays dirty tricks; combined with emotions and a dash of arrogance it's easy to fool oneself into taking risks. Knowing when to risk and knowing when to stay on the sidelines and observe is a critical success factor. You only take bets that come with situational circumstances, and ideally objective facts, that greatly weigh an outcome in your favor. In the world of inter-day volatility trading, it's often a combination of the time of the day, untapped liquidity pools, volume inefficiencies in order flow, and high impact news releases (CPI, unemployment data, etc). It's no surprise that government entities release major economic data nearly every day around the New York cash open which coincides with statistically significant volatility spikes. This is when you trade if you know what to look for. The first step is to define a set of objective facts setting the stage for your optimal environment. The next step is to verify the existence of these facts before placing capital at risk. Both steps take time, data, and market experience to develop and refine.

Risk Management

Ok... the environment is set, you like what you see and it's time to put hard money on the table. Without risk management as a pre-requisite step be prepared to get ran over by emotions. Get ready for an emotional ride across the planes of fear, hope, and greed. Trade going against you? FEAR! Trade starts to turn a bit less red? HOPE!! Trade goes green, passed your expectations? KEEP GOING - GREED!!!

These emotions are natural and must be in check before placing even one dollar at risk - otherwise you likely already lost. A few key questions every trader needs to work through as part of a trade plan established before entering any trade:

  • Do I fully understand the rules of the game (exchange/broker rules, contract rules, margin rules, trade order/execution rules, etc)?
  • Do I have enough experience with a wide variety of outcomes thereby limiting the unknown outcomes over time?
  • Have I calculated the maximum loss I'm willing to take for a single loss event?
  • How many consecutive single loss events can I live with over a certain duration?
  • Have I developed a set of early warning signs/red flags telling me I may be wrong or witnessing an early indication of an unfavorable or random outcome?
  • Do I have the discipline to take an early loss, admit an early defeat, and the confidence to try later as the red flags stack up against me?

Answering these questions confidently, coupled with historical data supporting your ideal trading environment, leads to a high degree of emotional control. You go into risk knowing the probabilities are in your favor, knowing (and psychologically accepting) the potential maximum loss, and objectively identifying early warning signs of failure. The active trade sequence then becomes more check-list oriented and objectively focused. If you believe in your process and data and still fail - that's a loss worth taking. In the long run your wins should outweigh your losses if your process is right.

Expectency

In the world of trading, poker, and a variety of other discretionary risk environments it is key for you to identify your engagement model once your optimal environment is in play. In the world of trading it could be a specific candle pattern, price inefficiency, open liquidity pools, volume signature, deviation from an average valuation, or a combination of sorts. Everyone has their own edge. What makes an edge a real edge is the data behind it. Your engagement model (or edge) should provide a high degree of expectancy (at least 70%) of success. Your edge should be tested in both your ideal and non-ideal environments with a statistically relevant sample size to provide a reliable data point. Without a data backed edge the value of your ideal environment rapidly decays. To summarize, a few key questions that can act as a checklist on the expectancy step:

  • Have I defined my engagement model in near robotic terms once my ideal environment materializes?
  • Do I have the data behind my engagement model to give me confidence in placing dollars at risk without fear or hesitation?
  • Is my confidence level in my engagement model high enough to accept a tolerable level of pre-determined loss?

If the answer is yes to all three questions you've got the wind behind your sail. Take the leap and work the checklist once you're on the risk. Don't look back.

Psychological Resiliance

Discretionary risk participation demands an abnormally high degree of psychological resilience. You've got to be mature enough to know when to accept your losses and exit - and wise enough to know your edge takes many trades to play out - not just one. For example, if your data presents a 70% win rate - that means you still lose 30% of the time. In a random distribution of events the 70/30 outcome plays out over time without knowing which specific event wins or loses. You combat this by taking only the bets when the environment and edge meets your data backed criteria. You have the discipline to stay on the sideline otherwise without fail. Following these steps take care of the hope and fear aspects. Greed is another tough one...easy to fix with a few simple rules like exiting the field once a certain profit target (or max loss limit) is hit. Rotating capital account groupings by trade opportunity throughout a given time horizon is also an excellent strategy in "boxing in" losses and/or "locking in" profits. Once a specific number (profit or loss value) for a specific account group is hit, you stop and move to the next account group only if your optimal environment and edge appear.

Closing Thoughts

We make decisions all day long and every decision comes with risk. Some decisions are mandatory while others are discretionary. The discussions here have been more in the context of discretionary risk participation in the world of inter-day volatility trading - however, taking the theory and application of knowing when to engage (bet), risk management, expectancy and discipline is applicable to a variety of decisions in our lives.

Thanks for reading and until next time.

/R