Duration risk is critical (if not the most critical) concept for bond investors and traders. Put simply, duration risk measures a bond's (or fixed income portfolio's) price sensitivity to interest rate changes. Key factors affecting a fixed income instrument's duration risk is its time to maturity and coupon rate. For example, a bond with a comparatively higher coupon rate and lower time to maturity provides a lower duration window for interest rate fluctuation. That's attractive.
I view duration risk with a different (but thematically similar) lens in my world of index futures. A quick refresher: our index futures instrument of choice is the Nasdaq 3-month expiry futures contract. The current ticker is "NQM2024", expiring in June of this year, traded on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange ("CME"). Generally there are three classes of participants in the index futures playing field each with different objectives and therefore different risk profiles.
(1) Institutions
(2) Hedge Funds
(3) Retail Traders
Institutional investors carry the market; think of organizations like commercial banks, investment banks, government central banks, sovereign wealth funds, pension funds, and the like. This class of investors move the market because of the shear size of their capital at risk. The 3-month expiry futures contracts (be it on indices, commodities, currencies, or any other traded risk asset), often acts as an insurance policy. Institutional investors use futures contracts to lock in price certainties to dampen price impact on their current portfolio holdings.
These investors buy at specific trigger points and typically hold through expiration. These investors are comfortable with a three month duration risk profile and often view any losses as a cost of doing business, ie insuring their core current portfolio against volatility.
Hedge funds often act in partnership with institutions to a degree and execute trades on their behalf. Hedge funds also just as often act independently and capitalize on volatility exposure across a variety of durations. In our market operations at Skywalk we aggressively seek low duration profiles of less than three to four hours. We hunt bursts of volatility we expect at certain points in the day, particularly during the New York morning and afternoon sessions. We are attracted to this type of low duration exposure because we limit our capital at risk to only market profiles that match our trading edge. We forego, however, the potential for significant upside beyond our initial trade plan. At the same time we avoid adverse price action. Some hedge funds seek wider duration risks throughout a three month expiration - perhaps days and weeks - often capturing thousands of points in price movement. Other funds seek duration risks measured in seconds using algos/bots to trade risk several times a minute (high frequency trading operations).
Finally we have retail traders. Retail traders often trade using hedge fund trading styles though seek low duration due to limited capital, limited leverage capability, and/or broker enforced limitations. That does not mean they do not make money; it only means they have a different duration profile often forced upon them.
The advantages of low duration are clear to us:
- A lower chance of a black swan event happening in the immediate minutes to 4 hours ahead vs anything longer
- Our data indicates our trading edge probabilities play out in our favor within a very specific time window often providing multiple trade opportunities within a given 4 hour window
- We don't like overnight risk (see point one...) and therefore end all trading operations daily in hard cash
There is nothing wrong with higher duration trading profiles if you are capitalized to absorb the potential volatility in price (or value) movement that comes with it... and you accept (or hedge/insure) black swan event risks. You are also likely to see significantly higher profit profiles if your longer-tail edge scenarios play out.
Diversification becomes critical ideally with non-correlated risks (aka idiosyncratic risks).
The pros here are venture capital and private equity firms. They are ok with longer duration risk exposure in their investments, generally have far greater visibility on operational risks via board seats or direct management placement/control, and crucially make several investments across potentially non-correlated companies in their portfolios. Maybe it's a number of companies/investments in the same industry or sub-industry attacking different problems. These pros are clearly comfortable with overnight risk and accept the risk of black swan events or other events leading to total loss such as bankruptcy, tech/competitive disruption, regulatory changes, and a variety of other threats. The success of a smaller portion of an overall VC/PE portfolio often leads to convex returns thereby absorbing the losses of the failures.
However, the black swan always lurks which is often catastrophic to the entire portfolio (and often entire industries too).
So what's your risk preference? Low duration with lower (but higher probability returns) you can bank now or long duration with higher (but variable probability returns) you may bank later?
We like the former.
/R